Almost everyone has heard the phrase “burden of proof,” but most people don’t fully understand what it means. That’s understandable. The burden of proof is an amorphous concept, and it changes depending on the type of case.
One of the best illustrations of the different burdens of proof is the pair of O.J. Simpson trials, one criminal and one civil. Same deaths. Same evidence, more or less. Two different results. How can two juries reach two different verdicts?
The burden of proof.
Let’s get into it, in plain English, with as little legalese as possible.
First, what is a “burden of proof”?
The burden of proof answers two questions:
Who has to prove it?
How convinced does the jury (or judge) have to be?
The first question usually has a simple answer: the person or entity bringing the case carries the burden of proof. In a criminal case, that’s the government. In a civil case, like a car crash, that’s the injured person, called the plaintiff.
The second question is where things get more complicated, because the answer depends on what’s at stake. The more serious the potential consequences, the higher the bar to clear.
Think of those bars like rungs on a ladder. Let’s start at the bottom and climb to the top.
The bottom rungs: reasonable suspicion and probable cause
Reasonable suspicion and probable cause live in the world of criminal law. They mainly govern law enforcement: who officers can stop, who they can arrest, and when they can search. They don’t really help a jury decide who wins at trial. Many thanks to my friend, a trooper with the Illinois State Police, for helping me explain these two concepts in plain English.
Reasonable suspicion
Reasonable suspicion is the lowest bar. It gives a law enforcement officer, like my trooper friend, the authority to briefly stop someone and ask questions. But the power isn’t unlimited. The law requires the officer to have specific facts suggesting something is up. Not a hunch. Not “he looked suspicious.” Articulable facts.
The analysis often turns on several pieces of evidence, including the officer’s training and experience. Some examples of things that may give rise to reasonable suspicion:
A vehicle matching the make and model of one reported to be driving erratically
A person fitting the description of a suspect in a recent crime
Conduct consistent with a crime in progress (see Terry v. Ohio)
Something that suggests a possible weapon or violation, like an unusual bulge in someone’s clothing
Reasonable suspicion generally isn’t:
Simply being present in a high-crime area
An officer’s “gut feeling” alone
Race, ethnicity, or appearance alone
General nervousness around an officer
Declining to answer an officer’s questions during a voluntary encounter
Probable cause
Once an officer has reasonable suspicion, the bar rises if they want to actually arrest someone. That’s where probable cause comes in.
Probable cause is what an officer needs to arrest a suspect or get a warrant to search. To meet it, the officer needs enough facts to convince a reasonable person that a crime probably happened and that the person being arrested probably committed it.
To be clear, probable cause isn’t enough for a conviction. It’s the price of admission to bring a criminal case in court.
Some examples that likely establish probable cause:
The officer personally witnessing the crime
Signs of intoxication that add up: erratic driving, failed field sobriety tests, and a preliminary breath test (PBT) showing intoxication
Contraband, like drugs or drug paraphernalia, in plain view
Possession of stolen property
A confession or admission
Probable cause likely isn’t:
An anonymous tip that hasn’t been corroborated
Being near someone suspected of committing a crime
Refusing to consent to a search
A hunch, or facts that only add up to reasonable suspicion
Meeting the probable cause standard usually just makes an arrest legal or a search lawful. It isn’t enough to get a conviction, or even to impose civil liability.
Preponderance of the evidence: where my cases generally live
This is the standard for most civil cases, including nearly every personal injury case my firm handles.
“Preponderance of the evidence” is a fancy way of saying “more likely than not.” That’s it. To illustrate it for a jury, I often give them a visual: picture the scales of justice. My client only has to tip them, even slightly, in their favor. I usually tell jurors they need to be 50.01% convinced my client is right.
That means my client doesn’t have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the other driver ran the red light. My client just has to prove it’s more likely than not that the other driver ran the red light, along with every other element of a negligence claim (more on those another time).
That isn’t always as simple as it sounds. Insurance defense lawyers are very good at adding weight to their side of the scale. They’ll present evidence of a pre-existing condition, point to a gap in treatment, or argue the plaintiff isn’t as hurt as they claim. (I’ve written about those insurance tactics before.) Every one of those is an effort to tip the scale back toward the defendant.
And here’s a wrinkle people don’t expect: defendants can take on a burden of proof of their own. If the insurance company argues you were partly at fault for your own injuries, it generally has to prove that. It’s their argument, so it’s their burden. (More on how comparative fault works in Missouri.)
Clear and convincing evidence: the middle rung
This is the least-discussed burden of proof, and one of the hardest to meet. But it shows up more often than you’d think.
Clear and convincing evidence means the jury must be firmly persuaded that something is highly likely true. Not just “more likely than not.” A lot more than that.
This standard generally applies when the stakes are higher than money, or when a claim is easy to make and hard to disprove. Depending on the state and the type of claim, it can apply to things like terminating parental rights, involuntary civil commitment, fraud claims, and the one I deal with most: punitive damages.
In Missouri, if you want a jury to punish a defendant, not just make them pay for the harm they caused, you have to clear this higher bar. By law, proving someone was careless isn’t enough for punitive damages. You have to prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that their conduct deserves punishment in the form of additional damages.
Here’s how that works in practice. In Missouri, I can’t include a punitive damages claim in my initial filing. Once the lawsuit is filed and evidence is discovered that could support punitive damages, I have to ask the court for permission to add the claim, backing up the request with that evidence. Both sides argue whether punitive damages should be allowed. If the judge agrees the evidence could support them, I get to make that argument to the jury. The jury then decides whether the clear and convincing standard has actually been met.
In my practice, this most often comes up in drunk driving cases. The evidence can include arrest reports, witness testimony, bar receipts, toxicology reports, or a DWI conviction.
As a lifelong St. Louis Cardinals fan, the easiest way I can explain clear and convincing evidence is baseball replay review. When an umpire makes a call on the field, it’s presumed correct. The team can challenge it, but the call stands unless the replay shows clear and convincing evidence it was wrong, such as the ball clearly in the glove before the runner’s foot hit the base. “Maybe” isn’t enough. You have to see it.
Beyond a reasonable doubt: the top of the ladder
This is the big one. Anyone who’s ever watched a police procedural has heard of “beyond a reasonable doubt.”
It’s the highest standard in the American legal system, and it’s the standard for finding a criminal defendant guilty. The government must prove guilt so thoroughly that no reasonable doubt is left in a juror’s mind. Courts often describe it as proof that leaves you firmly convinced the person is guilty.
Crucially, it doesn’t mean beyond all doubt. There are very few sure things in life. But under this standard, a juror who has a real, reasonable doubt, one grounded in the evidence or the lack of it, must vote not guilty. On the flip side, a juror whose only doubts are unreasonable (think “aliens did it,” or something equally outlandish) should vote to convict.
The bar is purposefully high because someone’s freedom is at stake, and in capital cases, their life. (I’m a staunch death penalty abolitionist, link below.) The people who built our legal system decided long ago that it’s better to let some guilty people go free than to lock up innocent ones. Reasonable people can disagree about where the line should be, but the line is there on purpose.
And no, courts won’t put a number on it. Lawyers love to toss out “95%” at happy hour, but judges almost universally refuse to quantify reasonable doubt. It’s a feeling of certainty, not a math problem.
So, back to O.J.
As most people know, in 1995, a criminal jury found O.J. Simpson not guilty of murder. The prosecution had to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, and that jury had reasonable doubt.
Two years later, in 1997, a civil jury found him liable for the wrongful deaths of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman. Same incident, same set of facts, different result. The reason? The burden of proof. The families only had to prove their case by a preponderance of the evidence: more likely than not.
The first jury was asked, “Are you firmly convinced he did it?” The second was asked, “Is it more likely than not that he did it?” You can answer “no” to the first and “yes” to the second without contradicting yourself at all.
The system worked.
Why this matters for your case
If you’re hurt and thinking about a claim, here’s what I want you to take away:
You don’t have to prove your case beyond a reasonable doubt. That’s the criminal standard. In an injury case, you have to show your version is more likely true than not.
Evidence still wins. “More likely than not” sounds like a low bar until the other side starts stacking weight on their side of the scale. Photos, medical records, witnesses, and consistent treatment are how you keep the scale tipped your way. (Here’s more on the evidence that wins injury cases.)
A criminal case and a civil case are two different things. If the driver who hit you was charged with DWI and the charge was dropped, or they were acquitted, that doesn’t automatically kill your injury claim. Different case, different burden.
That last point is the one I wish more people knew. I’ve talked to people who assumed they had no case because the criminal charges went nowhere. The O.J. cases are the most famous proof that it doesn’t work that way.
If you or someone you know has been hurt and you want to talk through whether you can meet your burden, get in touch with me here.
This post is general commentary based on my own experience and isn’t legal advice. Every case is different, and how yours plays out will depend on its own facts. For actual injury questions: hurtinstl.com. New here? Learn more about me.
Want to read more about my thoughts on the death penalty? Check it out below:
Cheers,



