Death penalty abolitionists aren’t pro-murder, despite what some people suggest. In fact, it’s quite the opposite. I’ve said it before, and it bears repeating: I’m staunchly anti-death penalty because I’m staunchly anti-violence.
I’ve wanted to explain my position in detail for a while, and the Department of Defense just gave me the perfect opportunity.
The execution you’ll be able to stream
This week, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that the Pentagon will livestream the firing squad execution of Nidal Malik Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter. The execution is slated for December 3 at Fort Hood, the site of the 2009 massacre. valleynewslive
If you don’t know the case, Hasan was convicted of killing 13 people and injuring 32 others on the base. valleynewslive
Let me be crystal clear up front: Nidal Hasan did something monstrous, and he may very well be a monster. Thirteen innocent people were taken from this earth far too soon. Countless others carry physical and emotional scars because of his depravity. Nothing in this post should be read as minimizing the lives lost or the suffering of everyone affected by this violence. I’m also not suggesting Hasan deserves sympathy or that his conviction should be questioned. Hasan deserves to spend the rest of his life in a cell.
What this post does question is his punishment: death by firing squad, livestreamed on the internet for the world to see.
It’s also worth knowing that Hasan is paralyzed. His paralysis was a result of the 2009 attack, but think about the message we send if a firing squad shoots a man in his wheelchair. That’s a hell of an image for the “shining city on a hill” to broadcast to the world.
In announcing the plan, Hegseth said, “We’ll make sure that people are able to watch it, that it’s public.” If the execution moves forward, it will be historic for several reasons, none of them good. It would be the first military execution since 1961, when an Army private was hanged. cp24
Whenever I see news of another person executed by the state, I get angry. When I heard Hasan’s execution was going to be livestreamed, I could only ask myself one question: if we need to livestream an execution, what the hell are we even doing?
Justice isn’t content. An execution shouldn’t have a like button, and it shouldn’t be shared across social platforms. When the government of the United States decides the best way to demonstrate its power is to broadcast an execution, it’s worth stepping back and asking whether this is a power the government should have at all.
I’ve been lucky enough to spend time with, and learn from, attorneys who represent people in post-conviction litigation: men and women convicted of capital offenses who have legal claims of innocence. That experience shaped my view. I think the most important question isn’t “Does this person deserve to die for their crimes?” It’s “Do we, as a people, deserve to kill them?” I’ve only ever come to one answer: no.
The Family Feud Murderer: Timothy Bliefnick
I want to talk about a case that’s a lot closer to home for me.
I went to Quincy University. Quincy is a small town, and like small towns everywhere, everybody knows everybody. Timothy Bliefnick is someone I know personally.
I started working out at a CrossFit gym Tim owned, and we became friends of sorts. I was 22, and Tim was eight or nine years older. He’d graduated from Quincy years earlier, gotten married, and had a couple of kids. He was living the life I thought I wanted: married, kids, a successful career. The American dream.
In college, Tim and I did many a workout together. We hung out at gym functions, and I even babysat his kids a couple of times. We stayed in touch after I graduated and hung out whenever I made it back to Quincy. We drifted apart after law school, for no reason other than that’s what happens when you stop seeing someone regularly.
In February 2023, I woke up to the horrific news that Tim’s wife, Becky, had been murdered in her Quincy home. Shortly after the news broke, Tim was arrested and charged with the crime. He’s been incarcerated ever since.
I’m not pretending I was especially close to Becky, or that I was somehow a victim of this crime. But the trial took an emotional toll on me. The prosecutor was one of my first mock trial coaches. The defendant was someone I used to look up to. The victim was someone I’d worked out with. And two of the prosecution’s witnesses were my college classmates.
I was very invested in the outcome. In May 2023, Tim was convicted of first-degree murder and home invasion. It was a planned, deliberate killing. At sentencing, the judge told Tim, “you researched this murder, you planned this murder, you practiced this murder.” He was sentenced to three life terms, and because they’re natural life sentences, he’ll never have a chance at parole. NBC Newswftv
It’s one thing to argue about the death penalty in the abstract, using crimes that only exist in the news. It’s another to think about someone you’ve worked out with, had beers with, and talked about life with, and try to reconcile that person with the man who murdered his estranged wife in cold blood. I haven’t found a good answer, and I’m not sure anyone can.
What I can say confidently is that Becky Bliefnick should be here. Her three sons should have their mother. But Becky was murdered, and Tim deserves to spend the rest of his days in a cell. I’m sure anyone familiar with the case agrees it was a tragedy and that Tim should die in prison. Some may believe the state should decide when he dies in that cell. On that point, I disagree.
Illinois already answered this question
The death penalty was never on the table for Tim. It was always going to be life in prison, because the murder happened in a state where the death penalty doesn’t exist. Had it happened across the river in Missouri, this is exactly the kind of case where prosecutors might have sought death. Planned. Premeditated. Researched in advance.
Illinois abolished the death penalty, and the reason why matters, no matter where you stand on the issue.
After Illinois reinstated the death penalty in the 1970s, the state ended up exonerating more people from death row than it executed. In fact, Illinois has the second-highest number of death row exonerations of any state, at 22, behind only Florida. An exoneration means the conviction was thrown out and the person was acquitted, had the charges dismissed, or was pardoned based on evidence of innocence. In other words, Illinois sentenced people to die for crimes they didn’t commit. deathpenaltyinfo
Because of the alarming number of innocent people sentenced to death, then-Governor George Ryan, a Republican, placed a moratorium on executions in 2000 and emptied death row in 2003. The state followed his lead and formally abolished the death penalty in 2011.
Back to Tim’s case. He got the harshest sentence the state offers, and he’ll die in prison. Becky’s family got a verdict, and a sentence that means what it says. A conviction will never bring back a loved one, but holding someone accountable may help with the grieving process.
It’s also important to remember what Becky’s family didn’t get: 20 years of their lives tied up in appeals, clemency hearings, and execution dates that get set, stayed, and reset, forcing them to relive the worst day of their lives over and over.
Life without parole protects the public. It punishes the guilty. And if, God forbid, the system ever gets it wrong, a living person can be set free. Science has yet to solve resurrection.
Why I’m against it
I like to think I know a little bit about a lot of things, and a lot about the legal system. When you look at the actual numbers, they aren’t kind to the justice system, especially when it comes to capital punishment.
The system convicts innocent people
Like any criminal defendant, a person in a capital case can only be convicted “beyond a reasonable doubt,” the highest burden of proof our legal system has. But “beyond a reasonable doubt” doesn’t mean beyond all doubt. It’s still a judgment made by human beings, and human beings can be, and often are, wrong.
How often does the system get it wrong? Since 1973, 202 people sentenced to death in this country have been exonerated. Put another way, there has been one exoneration for every 8.3 executions. There are few, if any, other areas of life where we’d tolerate that margin of error. deathpenaltyinfotheadvocatesforhumanrights
Exoneration takes years: years of coordinated legal work, years of investigation, and years of hearings. On average, death row exonerees spent 13 years under a death sentence before being cleared, and some spent more than 40 years fighting to prove their innocence. deathpenaltyinfo
Perhaps more importantly, of the first 200 exonerations, more than 70% involved official misconduct by police, prosecutors, or other government officials, and 65% involved false accusations or perjury. These weren’t honest mistakes or reasonable jurors reaching a different conclusion. They were wrongful acts by the state, which then used its power to sentence someone to die. deathpenaltyinfo
A state that can abuse its power to get a conviction shouldn’t also have the power to put that same person to death. I’m by no means saying that spending even a second in prison for a crime you didn’t commit is easy. But at least there’s a potential fix. There isn’t one when the state kills the defendant.
The only reason those 202 people were saved is that the system moved slowly enough for the truth to catch up with the lies their convictions were built on.
Race decides who lives and who dies
The death penalty is racist. Justice is supposed to be blind, but the death penalty is anything but. The single biggest predictor of whether someone gets a death sentence isn’t how heinous the crime was. It’s the race of the victim.
Of the 1,236 executions in the modern era, every victim was white in 76% of them, even though white people make up barely half of all homicide victims. An earlier study put it even more starkly: Black Americans make up about 47% of murder victims, but only 17% of victims in cases that ended in an execution. deathpenaltydeathpenaltyinfo
It gets worse when you look at the race of both the defendant and the victim. 23% of death sentences were imposed on Black defendants with at least one white victim, while only 2% went to white defendants with at least one Black victim. One study found that the odds of a death sentence were sixteen times greater if the victim was a white woman than if the victim was a Black man. deathpenaltyinfodeathpenaltyinfo
This isn’t new, and it isn’t a secret. Back in 1990, the federal government’s own General Accounting Office reviewed the research and found that in 82% of the studies, the race of the victim influenced whether a defendant was charged with capital murder or sentenced to death. The U.S. Supreme Court was presented with similar evidence in 1987, in McCleskey v. Kemp. It didn’t dispute the disparity. It upheld the death sentence anyway. deathpenaltyinfo
The wrongful convictions follow the same pattern. Of the people exonerated from death row, 65% are people of color, and 54% are Black. deathpenalty
A punishment handed out based on the color of the victim’s skin isn’t justice. It’s a lottery, and the tickets aren’t distributed fairly.
It doesn’t deliver what it promises
Supporters argue the death penalty deters crime and brings closure. I’m not convinced the evidence supports either one.
Deterrence assumes people weigh the consequences before they act. But many murders happen in moments of rage, intoxication, or desperation, when nobody is weighing anything. And the people who do plan, like Tim did, plan on not getting caught. The threat of a punishment you never expect to face doesn’t deter much. If the death penalty really deterred murder, you’d think someone would have proven it convincingly by now. As far as I can tell, nobody has.
The justice system is also in a constant battle with itself: a defendant’s due process rights on one side, and society’s understandable desire for a swift resolution on the other. Capital cases take decades to resolve because the Constitution demands that due process be protected, and executing someone ends up costing more than imprisoning them for life. Crucially, that keeps victims’ families locked into the case for years, if not decades.
It hands the government a power no government should have
It’s a bit of a silly concept when you say it out loud: killing people is wrong, so the government is going to kill you if you kill someone.
Polls consistently show most Americans don’t trust the federal government to do the right thing most of the time. The idea that we’d hand the same government that loses your paperwork at the DMV the power to decide who lives and who dies is, on its face, preposterous.
I don’t share that cynical a view of the government and its institutions. But I ultimately don’t believe the government should be the one deciding which crimes, and which defendants, deserve death. And instead of addressing that concern, my concern, the government is going to stream a firing squad executing a man in a wheel chair.
The other side of it
I believe death penalty supporters are sincere in their beliefs, and their views usually come from a genuine place.
The strongest of their arguments is about justice. Some crimes are so horrific that anything less than death feels like an insult to the victims. After all, Hammurabi’s Code called for “an eye for an eye.”
Hasan’s guilt isn’t in any real doubt. Thirteen families lost someone, and many people believe the punishment should match the crime. I understand that. If someone hurt my family, I’m not sure I’d feel any differently in the moment.
Some families of murder victims do support executions, and their voices deserve respect. Some researchers have argued the death penalty has a deterrent effect, though that’s heavily disputed. Others argue the racial disparities partly reflect differences between cases, like the circumstances of the crime or the defendant’s record, rather than bias alone. Many of the studies I cited control for those factors and still find the disparities, but it’s a fair point to raise.
There’s even an argument for the livestream itself: if the government is going to execute people in our name, maybe we should have to see it. Fordham law professor Deborah Denno, a death penalty expert, said livestreaming could make the process much more transparent and show the public everything capital punishment involves. irishnews
That last argument is the one I find most honest. If we’re going to do this, we shouldn’t hide from it. But I’d take it one step further: if we can’t stand to look at what we’re doing, maybe we shouldn’t be doing it in the first place.
Final thoughts
Nidal Hasan and Timothy Bliefnick did terrible, evil, unforgivable things. Both deserve to spend the rest of their lives in prison. One is scheduled to be executed on a livestream. The other will die in an Illinois prison cell, with no parole, no appeals circus, and no camera crew.
Only one of those outcomes can be undone if we get it wrong. That’s the one I’ll choose every time.
This post is general commentary based on my own experience and isn’t legal advice. Every case is different, and how yours plays out will depend on its own facts. For actual injury questions: hurtinstl.com. New here? Learn more about me.

